Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | rglovejoy's comments login

The problem here is that the real customers are the health insurance companies, Medicare, and the VA. They don't care about being delighted, they want inexpensive and rugged devices.

That's the problem Dean Kamen had with his iBOT wheelchair. They were very cool and their users loved them, but they went for something like $25,000 each and likely needed frequent maintenance.


Yup, if you’ve every watched network TV and seen the “Did you know Medicare will pay for X?” and wondered why, it’s exactly this.

If you want Medicare to pay for a product, you need a positive Coverage Determination. And if you get it, you just opened up a 50M person market (obviously a subset, since not everyone will need it) and all you need is the patient to say to their doctor “I want that” and it’s paid for.

It’s a heavily front loaded business, but if can get reimbursement, it’s basically paid for, you just need customers to ask for it (I’m obviously simplifying, since it varies by product type, but medical equipment is a great example).


Which is why a lot of the real money is in products that have wide appeal for non-disabled users.

This is where most of the bizarre "as seen on TV" products come from: The inventor made a tool for people with disabilities, found that the target market wasn't large enough to sustain a business, and frantically tried to pivot. Pivoting is hard when you already have a large inventory of hard products.

If you can build something that able-bodied people are not only willing to use but willing to pay extra for, then you're good to go.


yep, this is my argument


The way MIT persecuted Aaron is one reason why this alum no longer gives it money.


Did they?

Or did they just not speak out publicly against the prosecutor?


For the curious, everyone there has moved on to thedonald.win.


Which wack-packers were posting? Beetlejuice and Elephant Boy?


He was also in the Bob abd Doug MacKenzie movie 'Srrange Brew'.


MIT grad here. This is just one more reason I have stopped giving money to the Institute.


Why can't the person from Amazon reporting the bug just submit a pull request?


> I strongly believe that lower cost vocational education with group housing for 18-23 year olds is part of a solution to this problem.

In other words, the Army.


I don't think a bigger military is what the US needs, unless we were simultaneously shrinking the private sector money fire that the DoD provides fuel for. On an individual level, freedom-impeding loan debt is still less of a personal cost than what army recruits pay.


Well...


> If you want to look at per capita spending, the article says the US spends about 668 billion, divided by a population of 321 million, you get about $2080 per capita.

> So if you're calculating it that way, the US actually spends _less_ per capita than Finland.

Nobody is calculating it that way: the US does not have 321 million schoolchildren.


> Nobody is calculating [education budgets per capita]

The top-level poster did, in a (hopefully unintentionally) grossly misleading apples-to-oranges comparison:

> U.S. spent an average of $12,157 per student [...] Finland's education budget is €2,100 per capita [...] less than 20% of the spending!


I first heard the term 'maroon' from a Bugs Bunny cartoon, being used as an insult. I had no idea that it referred to escaped African slaves.


Bugs is just riffing on "moron".


Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: