Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | molossus's comments login

I've actually read about this before, but still never found any technical details about how the test works. My inner conspiracy theorist worries that a pharmaceutical corporation has bought this idea up.


I was interested to see what criteria were used to measure performance, but I haven't found a paper written about it. The most detailed information I could find was from here:

http://www.pancan.org/section_research/strategic_research_pr...

Essentially, this seems pretty damn early as far as results go. There will probably be a few years before we know it actually works or not.


Without wishing to rain on the kids parade...

There are two aspects to the reported work. The first is the use of carbon nanotube biosensors incorporating antibodies. Google shows they've been around for a while and are reportedly more sensitive than previous methods. The second is using the levels of mesothelin to diagnose pancreatic cancer, this is less widely established, but was also recently reported by a different lab (http://www.plosone.org/article/info%3Adoi%2F10.1371%2Fjourna...).

Putting the two together seems to be the work of Jack Andraka.


The fact that a 15 year old digested that information and put the two together is impressive in itself. Who cares if he was standing on the shoulders of giants? He bothered to gaze towards the horizon rather than at his own navel.


I agree. Also, it's possible that his work will actually directly lead to a test for pancreatic cancer, though that would take more work to establish, obviously.


Why would that be a problem?


The same reason that Exxon Mobile likes to keep patents on electric cars in its collection.


With all due respect, when you submit your own blog post to HN, you could at least have the courtesy to take 5 minutes to proofread it. And when you don't, it comes across as unprofessional and undermines any ethos you may have had, and I am very unlikely to read past the second paragraph.


While I applaud the effort, I do not understand the motivation. When I want to develop something, I use a desktop or a notebook, and I'm never away from one long enough that I would have no choice but to work on a mobile device.


Think about students in CS classes who already have their textbooks on their iPads but need to lug around a notebook just for some trivial coding. IMO this might be an interesting target group. HOWEVER the current language support does not really do that group justice. Add at least C, C++, Java and maybe Pascal and Basic (high school CS classes) syntax highlighting to cover a good portion of CS classes.


I would advise any CS student against tablets for the classroom.

A laptop is much more productive:

- A proper keyboard

- Ability to install whatever applications required for the classes

- No need of internet connection for software development

- Proper office like tooling for school reports


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: