Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | jtokoph's commentslogin

My guess would be cost. I don’t think Reddit had much, if any, revenue at the time and images would likely require orders of magnitude more storage.


Yeah, when imgur came about reddit was 99% text on the site. Hosting images would have been a huge step up in cost considering the user count. Then of course people realized that if imgur can make money on ads thanks to reddit's traffic, reddit could potentially make even more and it has been all down hill from there.


Not to mention the liability of hosting users' media, which would have needed costly moderation to ensure nothing too illegal made its way in.


How much protection do platforms have against user media submissions? If you implement a dcma/illegal report button tbat instantly takes the media down, maybe even logically, is that sufficient?


It might, but then you’ve created a whole new set of problems: if anyone can take down anyone else’s content with one click, they’ll do it against anybody they dislike just for the hell of it (this was the case on Tumblr for a brief period: the Report button almost automatically banned the user, until they immediately realized this was unworkable). So if you don’t want everyone to ban everyone, you need a moderation team anyway to handle false reports, and you’re right back where you started.


Agreed. I was mostly asking about any legal issues.

The problems are like you stated. We even see this happen with invalid dcma complaints in moderation-heavy environments. There are certainly safety rails such as rate limited reports per user, etc., but then you need some moderation anyway.

But if the legal requirement is, "take down media if the fbi comes knocking", maybe it's just easier to deal with it that way if there is no budget for moderation.


fyi it's DMCA


Nowadays just hosting text can get you in trouble if it is too pornographic in nature.


It’s probably now a lot easier to detect porn and automatically reject it. Set the filter to lean towards rejection for edge cases. You will lose out on racy bikini pictures, but maybe that is an acceptable compromise.


Reddit was a link aggregator till the recent shitty redesign. So image posts were just a post with a URL. You needed RES if you wanted to open the image inline with the post and comments.


Isn't storage cheap? Telegram advertises as free unlimited storage.


Storage multiplies and becomes more expensive once you're replicating across regions, backing up into an eternally growing corpus, and so on.

But the biggest impediment by far were internet transport costs. I mean, they're still onerous for a lot of media-heavy sites, but it was much worse at the time. Offloading that to third parties made an incredible amount of sense.

It's actually kind of bizarre that there is an Imgur "community". I know the operation ran at a massive money-losing proposition for quite some time.


Storage and bandwidth were way more expensive in 2009.


And yet imgur, with no revenue at all, managed to fill that gap.


They made hotlinking increasingly difficult, turned the site into a social network and sold ads against content. It is no longer a "image hosting site" the way it was back then, it was going bankrupt as well.


It still is the same old imgur for making posts. One button to upload, you get served your album link, right click image for direct link. Same as its been for 15 years. Just used it as such last week.


Imgur deleted a huge number of old reddit posts when retroactively banning nudity.

They broke the social contract of being a trusted host, that's the biggest change.


That's what I kept hitting based on normal W/S in gaming hand position (home-row offset by one)


You may never see it because Apple holds all of the streaming rights.


These are fun. I think Kingly would be better if solutions were unique. I was confused at first when I ended up in a situation with ambiguity and realized the puzzle just had multiple solutions (Sunday, June 29)


> I was confused at first when I ended up in a situation with ambiguity and realized the puzzle just had multiple solutions

You're right, Kingly is the newest out of the bunch and the least satisfying to solve because of that. It's getting a big rewrite under the hood this week, so should be much more fun to play to make it more deducable and less random


FYI, Your personal site seems to have some styling issues: https://imgur.com/0pDKc4l

Same thing in firefox and chrome on mac.


Thank you, I will have to look into it


Some people are worried about the new ownership: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40584606


Yeah. I've moved all my stuff to Ice, and that's what I recommend to friends now.


AppleTV Plus was just released on Android, wasn’t it? Quid pro quo?


Apparently there aren't any eSIMs in China that include a phone number. I'm not sure why.

I think this is why Apple releases the latest iPhones with physical SIM trays in China while the latest iPhones in North America are eSIM only


>while the latest iPhones in North America are eSIM only

It's US that's esim only. Canada and Mexico still has physical sim + esim option if you're willing to drive across the border.

https://www.apple.com/iphone/compare/

https://www.apple.com/ca/iphone/compare/

https://www.apple.com/mx/iphone/compare/


I was really confused and surprised that Meta was using a commercial product for indexing instead of building in-house...until I realized that they weren't talking about the AI search indexing tool at glean.com


glean.com is pretty awesome. The responses it generates will have citations from our internal Jira, Wiki, Slack, Github, etc.

It's also great for when I get pulled into a busy Slack channel and need a summary of what's been going on in there for the past week.


I'm a little bit confused is it the opensource that searches also in jira, wiki, slack, ..? https://github.com/facebookincubator/glean ?


I'm also confused, the link you shared is more akin to a sourcegraph alternative; but the parent is talking as if it's an LLM.

I'm going to guess that there are to completely unrelated products that share a name.

glean.com and your link (glean.software).


What's the pricing on it? Everything I see is "contact us".


Glean.com? We had an intro meeting with them, pricing only makes sense if you're in a first world country and have 100+ or maybe 150+ employees.

I recall pricing started at 50k USD per year but may be remembering incorrectly. Please take this with a grain of salt as they may have changed their pricing models or whatever - I just get really annoyed at the "contact us" stuff so thought I'd try to help out here.


Yeah this naming is questionable. This definitely introduces confusion in the minds of consumers but I'm not sure if it's actionable. Any lawyers want to give some "I am not your lawyer" opinions?


Meta's tool was started by at least August 2021. The Glean commercial product wasn't launched until September 2021.


It is a high burden to get a trademark on a 5 letter common English word. Usually can only be awarded after years in use and large popularity.


GPT-4 :)


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: