Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | geniium's comments login

That's so amazing! I wish I saw this at school while learning these by heart like a dumb student.


Surprised there are not more comment on this huge news.

Is there another post I missed that is more viral?


It makes you question what they mean by discovery. Is it not a discovery until it is published in Nature? On Arxiv this was a discovery in 2021. We can probably find a free energy channel in the YouTube haystack from a decade ago where the guy happened to arrange magnets in this order while going through permutations. Is that discovery or are only incumbent academics allowed to canonize science?


This is not really as simple as just going through the permutations. What this is in practice is a triumph of instrumentation. Before this, no one has imaged altermagnetic domain structure. The behaviour of these materials is intrinsically linked to what happens in the micro- (or nano-) structure.

There are two challenging things here that makes this a discovery. One, making the material, which is extremely difficult to verify as altermagnetic due to the nature of measuring these materials. Two, the measurement, which combines two techniques to distinguish this as separate from antiferromagnetism.

It is a huge push forwards for the budding field since it provides a really nice way to go to a large-scale synchrotron with your altermagnet and study it in detail.


Oh, okay I think I understand.

This would have to scale down to the quantum domain to be an actual thing and scaling back up means we bring non-commutative physics into the classical world.


They didn't use macroscopic magnets to form the alternate pattern or the swirls, and they are stable. If you have a link to a YouTube Channel with a similar result, it would be nice to see it.

Also, do you have a link to the arxiv post of 2021? It's a lot of time. This article looks like studing how to "see" the pattern. Perhaps the old one was about the material and general properties.


I was actually thinking of the engineering-minded people who experiment with permanent magnet electric motors out of intuition. The bit about free energy was hyperbole of mine.

From 2021:

https://arxiv.org/abs/2105.05820 This is the numerical discovery.

I'm trying to decide if we are intentionally 'translating' these ideas from pure imagination down into technological applications through intermediate 'realms' of quasi-reality, or if building stuff with just intuition can still be accepted in the 21st century. The BS is just piled too high for me and my trust in technology is not great. Sometimes I wonder if we are just having a mass psychosis in a field of mud.


It looks similar but I'm not sure it's the same.

IIUC the new article is about taking a "photograph" of the magnetiation in a real sample, and the old article is a theoretical prediction. Perhaps the new article should be presented as a confirmation instead of a discovery, but press releas are full of omisions and overhype.


It's probably not groungbreaking. The title is misleading.

It's just a new arrangement of the spins in material. It may be useful to get better transformer or something, like improve them 1%, or in 30 years it may cause a huge unexpected thechnology revolution and my comment would look silly. There are similar discoveries of new materials with weird properties every month. Unless you work in that area, it is probably safe to ignore it for the next 10 years until it has some aplications. (Or you may enjoy reading the technical details.)


Welcome to the post science world


There's definitely fatigue around science news where media orgs massively over inflate or prematurely celebrate. Without actually being in the field yourself it's impossible to tell if any discovery is a nothingburger, 20 years away from meaning anything, or about to change the world. And most of the time it's the first two.


Currently my source of truth is Sabine Hossenfelder, on YouTube. Worth a look.

EDIT: she has a video on this[0] from 9 months ago! There you go.

[0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D0st_6sE7Bk


That's true, but I was more commenting on the loss of science from the public subconscious and our media outside of 7 second tiktok videos that link to current trends.


Very interesting read! Gives some idea on how to integrate data that are not easy to access. Thanks


This is amazing


TL;DR: bye bye Google


And that’s why people should not trust Apple Intelligence : the partnership with open ai and toward data security is a real risk.


None of your data is sent to OpenAI other than the text you type.

So no different to using their website.


Interesting. I am an ai enthusiast but I don’t understand exactly what your product does. Run locally ? Run remote on HF? Would love more info.


Both! You have the option of using HF’s HuggingChat or switching to a local model using a keyboard shortcut


Is it just me or the camera man has Parkinson !?


This seems to be very political- related to the upcoming Brazilian votes and freedom.


Every now and then I see post like this.

Am still surprised there isn’t a solution to make the iPad a real dev machine.

Apple must really not want us to do this.


Apple is in a pickle because of background app restrictions.

On Android, OEMs and App developers play tricks to hack those restrictions and you end up with awful user experience and poor battery life.

If apple loosens background restrictions to allow for IDEs, compilers, terminals and any app that needs to keep a socket or child process alive -- an entire league of background battery-killers will hit the app store

This is a case of Apple discipline in favor of the iPad platform.


The apple silicon laptops get pretty close to all day battery life with real multitasking. I guess the iPad has a smaller battery, but I would be interested to see how long running macOS on an iPad would last.

Apple could even support switching the iPad into a desktop mode, which would be real macOS. Could be similar to how the Steam Deck switches to KDE.

I suspect the real reason is Apple wants the iPad to remain a consumption device so they can sell you more than one device.


Oh yeah that's a good point I forgot. They have always been very protective of the "user experience" - battery life beeing a big topic there.


battery life and responsiveness (cpu budgeting)


cpu budgeting, love that word!


thanks! let's keep this complement trend going.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: