Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | BestHackerOnHN's commentslogin

OMG you win HackerNews today with this comment! Super HackerNews!!!


Comments like this are what turn me off about this website. Entitled, much?


Apart from the M1 comment, I think the commenter voices a reasonable concern and isn't hostile or antagonistic


He complimented the app and made a decent suggestion..


> Out of instinct to defend YC companies

Credit to Garrry for realizing he is very biased and offering a tepid "apology."


He's an idiot


ICYMI

> In 2024, Tan attracted criticism for a profane tweet wishing death on seven of the 11 members of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors. In a later apology, he said he was referencing a rap track.

https://www.sfchronicle.com/sf/article/garry-tan-tech-exec-a...


I sometimes think private individuals in America are held to much higher standard than public representatives. Somehow, it is like "all things considered" my party did the right thing under the circumstances but that "all things considered" leniency is not shown to private individuals.


> It's refreshing to see this compared to lots of other projects that always seem to claim to be the best solution for everything.

Agreed 100%, hencq!


Your effort did not go unnoticed :-)


Wow this is so cool - HackerNews post of the day IMO!!!


> I don't usually ask for citations on comment threads

No - please do!!! It'll ensure we have robust discussions on this great site!


Loving this classic HackerNews-type discussion!!!


> "the only reason we can have something as fundamental as FIRE is because of living things" is a bit of a mindblowing realization.

I am fairly confident living things did not create FIRE.


Well, we (broadly speaking) did not create the concept of a plasma phase of matter, but fire as we know it is only possible because of free oxygen. Fire, for the most part, is just another name for rapid oxidation.

Even some things that can burn without air (e.g. magnesium) typically only burn because they are so hot that they cause H2O to separate.

Obviously stars exist, so there are other ways of getting to plasma, but oxygen is what makes terrestrial fires possible.

So yes -- living things created fire!


> Even some things that can burn without air (e.g. magnesium) typically only burn because they are so hot that they cause H2O to separate.

I'm not positive about magnesium, but also most of them only burn because we've converted them to materials that don't exist in nature. Eg it'll only be found as oxides (ie already burnt) and then we put some energy or chemicals in to get the form we want.

If it _can_ oxidize as found in nature, there has to be some good reason it didn't already do it over ~billions of years.


Well, we didn't start the FIRE. It was always burning since the world's been turning.


Bare rocks and water don’t burn, they are already oxidized. Life chemically reduces CO2, providing material than can support combustion.


Without living things, who would retire early? The markets aren't going to trade themselves.


Thank you!


Very cool! Thanks for sharing!


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: